On online presence and loyalty cards

Recently, I participated in a seminar about children’s usage of social media, led by Harry A. Valetk and hosted by the Oxford Internet Institute. The discussion was excellent and included many soul-searching topics such as the end of anonymity in today’s connected society, or the conflict of interests between users of social networks and the commercial organisations running them. At some point, of the discussants said ‘… that’s why many marketers I know refuse to be on Facebook – that’s where they draw the line’.

I am a marketer. I choose not to join leading loyalty card schemes like Tesco’s ClubCard because of the type and range of data collected and the company’s analytical ability. Yet, I am on Facebook, and on LinkedIn, and on Twitter, and have a personal website, and I blog, and… you get the picture. Why would I do that?

I choose to have an online presence because, in my view, not ‘being’ on Facebook does not mean that I am not on Facebook. In other words, even if I do not have an account with this (or other) commercial service, there will still be information about me in that platform. Friends may tag me on images that they upload, geo-tag their location when they visit me and so on. Indeed, you just need to refer back to the opening lines of this blog post, where I disclosed that Harry had recently been in Oxford. That may be irrelevant for most, but an important insight for some person or organisation.

Am I upset that information about me is being collected and stored by some commercial organisation whose main goal is to profit from it?

Yes, definitely – that is why I do not hold certain loyalty cards. The difference between store loyalty cards and social media platforms is that in the former the relationship is between the organisation and me only, whereas in the latter it is between the organisation, me and others (friends, business contacts, students, etc.)

As David James puts it: ‘Your personal reputation… (is) priceless. It’s a bit like your personal credit rating and needs to be cherished. So, you need to take extra special care that they are intact and the truth is being told’.

Being online, you can influence the information available because you decide what and when to post. Moreover, you have increased awareness about what information is released about you because you receive notifications that your friends tagged your image, mentioned your username, shared your blog’s content, etc.

And that, in turn, helps you shape your online presence to make sure that the truth is being told. At least the truth that matters.

Where do you draw the line in terms of what to disclose, how and to whom?

4 thoughts on “On online presence and loyalty cards

  1. Totally agree Ana.  You have the opportunity to manage your presence if you’re prepared to put some time and effort in.  Not much effort but after all the same. As Shakespeare said in one of his plays (too old to remember which):Who steals my purse steals trash; ’tis something, nothing;
’Twas mine, ’tis his, and has been slave to thousands;
But he that filches from me my good name
Robs me of that which not enriches him,
And makes me poor indeed.


  2. Sounds like I would have found this seminar interesting – I get really frustrated by children setting up Facebook accounts and then expecting you to become their friends (I always refuse, no matter how much it offends!) It means I spend countless amounts of time explaining to my 11 year old why he can’t have a FB account or chat online via MSN or XBox Live. Whilst I appreciate that this ever evolving world of technology means my children shouldn’t be left behind, surely developing social skills with real people face-to-face is far more important?


  3. It was very interesting, but also a bit sad when we talked about sexting, sextortion, etc… But on your point about Facebook for children: allowing our children to create a Facebook account, in my view, also tells them that it is OK to lie (about your age, in this case) and to ignore limits that are set up, arguably, for their own safety (just like speed limits).Thanks, Becca.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s